We very much appreciate many of your wishes, thoughts and prayers during this difficult time. We realize that just like our staff, many people are emotionally connected to every member of our Zoo family. Because of that connection, we fully understand why some have questions regarding what happened to our bison.
For those who didn’t have a chance to view it, last evening we did post on this page describing what happened.**
We’d like to try and answer questions that some have raised and give as much correct information as possible. While we don’t think this will lessen the feeling of loss that we’re all experiencing, we do hope it will create a common understanding around what happened.
Question: Has a bison at ZooAmerica ever drowned or been euthanized in the past?
Answer: We’ve never lost or euthanized a bison, or any large animal, due to flooding at any time – even including the flooding that occurred during hurricanes that have struck Hershey. Suggestions that bison were lost during Hurricane Ivan are incorrect.
Q: Are there any other animals that have perished from the flooding?
A: There have been no other losses reported at this time. Reports that our wolves passes away are incorrect. All of the wolves were relocated to the highest portion of their enclosure during the storm. All four wolves are fine and the flood waters have currently receded from their enclosure.
Q: Did you have a plan in place and did you feel that it was effective?
A: We do have a flood response plan, which we began implementing on Monday. Based on our past experience and during other milestone storms, our plan to first remove animals to higher ground and then, if necessary, relocate the animals has always been effective in securing their safety.
This, however, was truly unprecedented flooding. Such unforeseen acts of nature are difficult to plan for – as all public and private entities within Derry Township discovered.
Q: Why didn’t you tranquilize and move the larger animals earlier in the week?
A: Tranquilizing and moving large animals is stressful on them – and we only do it when absolutely necessary, not in the instance of every flood warning. Based on more than three decades of experience, the practice of moving the animals to higher ground would have given us enough time to tranquilize the bison and relocate them, should flooding become severe. But, again, the speed and ferocity of this storm was unlike any we’ve ever encountered. When the bison enclosure flooded so quickly, tranquilizing them become impossible, for once they were tranquilized they would have immediately been submerged in the flood water and drown.
Q: Were the bison moved to higher ground?
A: Yes. They were moved to the highest ground within their enclosure earlier in the week.
Q: Why did you wait to close until noon on Wednesday?
A: The fact that we were open to the public did not alter or impede our animals’ safety. Animal relocation did not begin once we were closed; it had been ongoing throughout the week. The safety of our animals, employees and guests is our top priority. It always has been and always will be. We were working to ensure that our animals are in a safe conditions, according to the plan we have in place, throughout the week.
As we said last evening, this has been a very emotional and trying time for those at the Zoo – both our animals and employees. While we are all saddened by the loss of the bison, we must acknowledge the heroic efforts of the Zoo staff – some of whom have been working without sleep on behalf of the animals. Many willingly put themselves in harm’s way in order to protect and rescue the animals in their care (even rescuing wild animals that were in distress at the same time). We are extremely proud of the efforts of the Zoo staff, and share this loss with them.
** Hersheypark’s correction to last evening’s post: A single bison was euthanized after unsuccessful attempts to rescue the first bison resulted in that bison drowning.

152 comments
Comments feed for this article
September 9, 2011 at 12:44 am
Jendi
Thank you for your clear and courteous response. My sympathies and best wishes in dealing with the rest of this natural disaster.
September 9, 2011 at 12:58 am
rebecca montini
Thank you for explaining a lot of questions. It is more comforting to get a better understanding of the true situation. My heart goes out to all the zoo staff for their loss. I will truly remember the awesome presence the Bison had there at Zooamerica.
September 9, 2011 at 1:02 am
EJ Gabriel
Thank you for sharing. I certainly suspect that nearly everyone who has left comments realized that much love was put into saving the animals. My hope is though, that as individuals learn from natural disasters, that Hershey admin, that is those who do plan for disasters there at the zoo and at the park, take the extra steps that were missed for these poor animals. I realize bison are tremendous animals but as someone who works for an emergency response federal agency, we must learn from these sad times so that we never have to relive them again. That is the only way we can truly honor the memory of what we lose…by learning and doing the next step to keep it from happening again.
It was the loss of so many pets during Katrina that we now have such a strong emphasis on taking our pets with us when evacuated….Katrina sensitized society to the importance of animals in the lives of humans. That in some way, honors the memory of pets lost.
My heartfelt thoughts to all at ZooAmerica.
September 9, 2011 at 1:04 am
Anonymous
Good start, please continue to read the comments to the other release and continue to answer the questions. Begin with:
Q: Have you taken inventory of the prairie dogs and is each is custody?
September 9, 2011 at 1:12 am
Anonymous
What were you thinking? It is atrocious that the animals met their end in this manner. Very poor planning on everyone’s part. The person in charge should be replaced. My sympathies to the dead animals not to the poor decision makers.
September 9, 2011 at 1:14 am
Anonymous
What were you thinking? There was definitely very poor planning. The response was too slow. You always implement a plan that takes into account the worse case scenario. Apparently the response here was to assume all would be well. The decision-maker should be replaced. If the zoo can’t keep the safety of it’s animals first, then maybe there shouldn’t be a zoo. My sympathies are with the dead animals not with the people committing these atrocious acts.
September 9, 2011 at 1:20 am
Anonymous
Thank you very much for the communication. Sad time all around. But please take care of those awesome wolves, they are calling for more rain in the coming days, as I am sure you are aware.
September 9, 2011 at 1:28 am
Brittany Dubree
Sorry…
Although you have very good representatives preying on the sympathy of people, the only sympathy I have goes towards the animals.
It’s always easy to cover up what we did wrong, rather than take the proper precautions and do the right thing.
We were already warned of this coming hurricane season and the damage it could bring. We have already seen it. What would it have taken to make you believe you should have moved the animals out completely?
Residents of Maryland and even surrounding areas of PA, including Hershey saw how bad the conditions were getting and evacuated the area.
You’re fully aware of how low-lying the grounds of Hershey Park are, but you wanted so badly to not have to go through the effort to move everything out. Residents said starting MONDAY it could be seen that there would be problems with flooding.
The lives of animals that you claim to “rehabilitate” you lost due to your incompetence and they probably would have been able to survive better in their own habitat.
I would never associate myself with this “zoo.” If you can’t take care of the animals then you should not be running this. Do you know how many children will now associate ZooAmerica with “the place the animals died?”
Children watch the news and can understand that Hershey Park is the place that killed animals.
Good luck explaining that one to five year olds.
September 9, 2011 at 1:29 am
Lori
So sad I’m sure the staff did all that they could under the circumstances.This was a most trying time. People should not make judgements,when they were not there to see how hard it must have been for the Zoo staff.
September 9, 2011 at 1:30 am
Jodi
Thank you for your communication; I can appreciate the emotional attachment that the caregivers have for these animals. It is horrific that many of the accusatory comments are coming from individuals who can’t comprehend the magnitude of the flooding, and how quickly it occured–without warning! Hershey has never flooded to the extent as it has in the past two days. I was very scared watching the video of one of the caregivers wading in waist high, fast moving water, attempting to rescue one of the bison. It was very obvious they were doing everything possible-even putting themselves in extreme danger.
September 9, 2011 at 1:33 am
Amy
Thank you for your answers. I can only imagine what all the animal caretakers are going through. Another thought for everyone to think about here is that these animals are not house pets that come when you call. I am sure its not easy to get them to do what you want on a normal day, let alone when they are frightened.
September 9, 2011 at 2:37 am
Anonymous
I work as a volunteer at our little, local zoo… For those of you who think this zoo didn’t have proper planning in place, I would suggest you go volunteer there… you will soon find out that the zoo keepers and all of the other staff and volunteers care for these animals like they are children… but sometimes you just can’t outplan mother nature…I am saddened by the cruel comments – do people really think the zoo wasn’t working feverishly from last w/e? Remember folks, all of the animals that were relocated are NOT domesticated animals – you can’t just put them on a leash and they walk quietly by your side… it takes a LOT of time to move wild/ undomesticated animals. Pens have to be readied, animals caught, some sedated, and only then can they be moved…It is not a walk in the park…So please rethink this. If this zoo’s employees are anything like the ones I work with, they will carry this gut-wrenching day with them for a long time…and just as you wouldn’t kick a dog when it’s down, please have the same respect for humans.
September 9, 2011 at 2:53 am
Anonymous
I wonder what PETA will think of this?????
September 9, 2011 at 2:54 am
Anonymous
There is no excuse period.Flood warnings all week !! We will not support Zoo America again . Maybe next time when it rains for a week and there is a flood warning you will move the animals earlier.
September 9, 2011 at 3:08 am
sad in pa
1 week of nothing but rain !! Flood warnings !! Zoo America let there animals down shame on you !! I am right up the road from you guys and i will not support you again and i am hoping our school district does the same..
September 9, 2011 at 3:32 am
Anonymous
Very sad to hear of the loss of the animals. My 4 year old even wanted to say prayers at school today for them hoping that the angels are taking good care of them now. Really hope you think about putting some type of memorial up with pictures and maybe their life there at the zoo. They might be animals but they deserve something to be remembered!!!!!!!!
September 9, 2011 at 3:41 am
Melissa VanKirk Temple
I am saddened by the loss of the bison and I understand about the rain and the flooding but I have to ask the person verbally attacking the zoo and it’s staff on here, will you do the same to the people who got caught off gaurd by the flooding and how fast it took many areas if the same were to happen to them. The zoo was following the plans set in place for flooding at the zoo. NO ONE could have predicted that this would rank up there with and above the 1972 floods in pa. It wasn’t till after flooding started that most thought it may get that bad. I will continue to support Hershey Park and Zoo America. I would also love to see some sort of fundraising done to replace the bison lost by this tragic NATURAL DISASTER. We will be looking forward to our 4th grade field trip in May 2012 and hopefully to seeing new bison in the bison pen. Our thoughts are prayers go out to the zoo staff who tried desperatly to save these beautiful animals I am sure they are very upset by this.
September 9, 2011 at 4:13 am
Anonymous
To the previous commentor…What a crock and cliche’, everyone says that about every job out there, don’t want to hear it. I don’t “need” to volunteer there or anywhere else to understand what goes on behind the scenes on a daily basis, I have a career and have had to make difficult choices in the 25 years of doing it. “SHAME ON ALL OF YOU!!!!!!! SHAME ON YOU!!!!!!! Irregardless of any explanation you give, woah is me is what you sound like because of what you had to endure at that very moment. Believe me I completely understand what you must have been experiencing at the time, I’ve had two animals of my own that had to be put down. Aren’t these situations about rescue first not recovery?? I also understand the power of nature and that we can never expect the unexpected, however, I have to say, that we have had warnings, did you not listen?, not hear them? where were you all this last week. I am, as well as alot of others, shocked and still effected by the officials at Zoo America for not being able to head those warnings in advance. Because of this, I will not be a supporter of Zoo America for a very long time. I am an animal lover and know the heartache that accompanies the sadness of a loss, but also believe there had to be a way to have saved these animals, OH YEAH, PREPAREDNESS. Ever heard of it? Bison do not know any better. They are living in a place that is not of their natural habitat. They have no choice but to be dependant on humans to feed them and give them drinking water, yet to be constantly looked at and I’m quite sure taunted by some. Some life. Yet to be shot by those who they have no choice but to trust is absolutely astounding. I’m boycotting and am joined by many others. Hershey will by no means received any support from me in any way shape or form. SHAME ON YOU ALL!! I DONT’ KNOW HOW YOU SLEEP AT NIGHT KNOWING HOW YOU TREAT THESE ANIMALS!!!
September 9, 2011 at 4:15 am
Anonymous
Anyone interested in clearing up the rumors about the death of coyotes and others in the zoo?
September 9, 2011 at 4:23 am
my opinion
Shame on you Hershey evacuation planners! I hope those poor animals haunt you for the rest of your life.
On the other hand, I am verrrry thankful that all of the zoo workers did what they could do to rescue what animals they could. No one is putting the blame on you. We have had flood warnings ALL week, what was the person in charge of this thinking? Someone needs to be held accountable for overlooking these warnings. Animals should have been moved last Friday. And I agree with doing something to remember the fallen animals.
September 9, 2011 at 4:24 am
Anonymous
Something just does not sit well with me. There should have been a better evacuation plan than moving the bison to higher ground.The image of the TWO floating bison that is spreading all over facebook will never be erased from my mind. I am sad, heart broken and pray these beautiful animals have peace.
September 9, 2011 at 4:53 am
Melissa VanKirk Temple
ok in 2006 no animals were lost at the zoo due to flooding I am assuming they were going on that and that is what there current evecuation plan was based on 16.1 ft in an area where flooding starts at 7 ft seriously who the **** knew a week ago that the water would rise to OVER 26 ft. I am thinking noone even knew till yesterday it would get that bad. I am positive they will learn from their mistake and a new plan will be put into place. Also I am not affraid to sign my name to my comments. It is easy to spue negative comments when you are Anonymous. If you want the zoo to own up and take responsibilty (which I think they are) then I think you all should own up and take responsibilty for what you are posting. I do have animals and we help on my in-laws farm as well and they had flooding due to all this as well and we did what we could to keep the animals on the farm safe but you can only do based on past knowledge, there comes a point when the past knowledge is not enough you just have to learn from that and go forward. 7ft flooding starts, 16.1 ft crest in 2006, 26 feet 9/2011 even with warnings noone could have known. I do not nor have I ever worked at the zoo or any other zoo, I am just a mother of 3 kids who love Hershey and the zoo sharing my opinions and thoughts.
September 9, 2011 at 5:05 am
Anonymous
The pen that they were in is basically flat. What was the thought process from taking them from one flat spot closer to the creek to another flat spot away from the creek?
September 9, 2011 at 5:43 am
Anonymous
I’m very heartbroken to hear that these animals lost their lives due to such tremendous and unexpected flooding. Mother nature sure threw us all a curve ball! I feel where a lot of you are coming from by being negative, we’re heartbroken and angry, but on the other side I can’t be mad at the staff. At least they were there helping or even volunteering their lives. I wasn’t there to save them so I can’t say these people are horrible. The staff could have thought, “These animals are wild, they’ll be fine, their instincts will kick in and they’ll survive. I have my own family and life to tend to and get out of this area.” But they didn’t. They were there. Hopefully, when they start clean up in the zoo someone will create plans to redesign the bison area and all the other animals’ areas so that if anything like this or any other disaster were to happen the animals will be safe. I’m sure if the staff had known to expect extreme flooding of 20+ ft within a few hours that they would have moved these animals and would not have waited until the last minute and allow the bison to be in danger and also themselves. I’m sure their thoughts were not to kill the animals. It takes an animal lover a lot of thinking to finally decide that death is best. Just like a family member. Unfortunately, time and resources were not on their side.
September 9, 2011 at 7:53 am
Brad
“Q: Why didn’t you tranquilize and move the larger animals earlier in the week?
A: Tranquilizing and moving large animals is stressful on them – and we only do it when absolutely necessary, not in the instance of every flood warning. Based on more than three decades of experience, the practice of moving the animals to higher ground would have given us enough time to tranquilize the bison and relocate them, should flooding become severe. But, again, the speed and ferocity of this storm was unlike any we’ve ever encountered. When the bison enclosure flooded so quickly, tranquilizing them become impossible, for once they were tranquilized they would have immediately been submerged in the flood water and drown.”
Who said you ever had to traquilze the bison? The fact that they were so close to the creek and the fact that Zoo America knew of and had ample warning that there could have been flash flooding should have been enough to warrant them to move the animals off the grounds of the zoo. They never had to be traqulized, they could have enlisted the help of one of the hundreds of horse farms; or one of the other zoos within a hundred miles to corral, transport, and keep them until the danger was lower.
Simply put, Zoo America was negligent. All the people that are in an uproar about this really want is for them to acknowledge they made a mistake, apologize to the public for said mistake, and a change to be made in procedure that is publically shown (mabye a publication of what exactly there procedure is in the event of a flood or natural disaster) so we know that they have corrected the sitation.
September 9, 2011 at 9:05 am
Anonymous
I just feel that it is in poor taste for the spokesperson to first state that both bison were euthanized. Now that the truth comes out and they cannot cover it up the story has changed – one bison was euthanized and ONE DROWNED. In my eyes, the truth should have been told from the beginning. What else are they hiding, they already lied to the public once? What a horrible death for those animals! I also feel sorry for the animal caretakers. It sounds like the bison or any other animal should not have been located in the enclosed area (death trap) that is prone to any flooding.
September 9, 2011 at 12:55 pm
Anonymous
Thank you and all my consolences go out to all the Zio keepers and your animal friends!!! Sorry for your loss.;(
September 9, 2011 at 1:15 pm
Daniel
Thank you to all zoo staff for saving all but the bison. We respect your efforts and feel your sadness at this time. All the incorrect information that was being published shows a rush to judgement.
Please stay strong and best wishes with the clean up and restoration of your zoo. I will certainly make it a point to visit soon and show my sympathy and support.
There were other deaths from the flooding, human deaths. Lets not forget that we cannot control everything that happens. We pray and reflect for all those that lost their lives, human and otherwise.
September 9, 2011 at 1:46 pm
Anonymous
there is a Bison Farm in Hawley PA, I would bet if you had called them they would have taken those Bison in until the flooding was over. Very upset about this
September 9, 2011 at 1:59 pm
Anonymous
Your organization must be extremely unorganized and I question your ability to run and operate a zoo. If your management staff were prepared, this entire situation would have been avoided. Why didn’t you move all the animals to higher groud? What were you waiting for? The local news channels were covering the story for days prior to the flooding. I find Zoo America’s actions sickening!
September 9, 2011 at 2:01 pm
Anonymous
To all of the naysayers out there:
Your emotional anger comes from a love for animals and that is to be commended HOWEVER you are all taking the easy path of least resistance and standing on the sidelines judging what “COULD HAVE BEEN”. And, if you all know better and could have done better then you should all send resumes in immediately to various disaster response units; because you have it all figured out.
I do not work for any Herhsey organization and I doubt many of you do either so you cannot say what was or was not done unless you were there the days and hours leading up to this. Guessing will not fix this or bring lives back.
It is very sad that the animals have passed in such a way but perhaps your energies could be best spent praying for the ‘families’ surrounding these animals as you would if a human life were lost. Or, in fact, all of the lives lost; human and animal. And, if you feel you can make a difference maybe you could also spend your energies volunteering for the ASPCA or any disaster relief organization where there is still much to be done.
September 9, 2011 at 2:33 pm
Anonymous
you commented on the necessity to euthanize those bison, and that the rumor of the wolves is untrue, but what about the prairie dogs? Are they not important? and the fact that tranquilizing and moving large animals may be stressful but its a hell of a lot less stressful than to be drowning in water and then shot. You cover those animals with tarps and moved them with a bulldozer. how in the world is that better then sedating them and doing the same thing with them ALIVE. the zoo stayed open to gain profit. you moved the animals to higher ground, but those animals should have been cared for and had all the necessary things on hand to prepare for immediate removal. even if you didnt THINK the water would get so high, the plan for action should have been laid out in advance and those bison should have been taken from harms way.
i understand that at that point there was nothing else to do besides euthanize the bison, fact is it shouldnt have gotten to ‘that’ point. something should have been done sooner, and your kidding your selves to think or say nothing could have been done sooner,
zoo america behaved in selfish and risky behavior at the expense of animals LIVES.
September 9, 2011 at 2:36 pm
Concerned Guest
Is a full report of all animals lost in the flood ever going to be made public?
It seems that the story of the two bison changed once already, so then again how can we trust any of the imformation you put out? In the end the truth does get out, but it is sad to see misinformation being initially distributed.
Also, I am wondering about what “High” area is there in their pen? It is pretty much flat, 2 feet is not really higher. Seeing the Elk area is much higher and the two animals live together in the wild, one would have thought they should have been moved there a lot earlier than when the water was already flowing. Just having the park open during the day proved the lack of common-sense of the management of ZooAmerica and the Hershey company. Flash flood reports were being issued for 24 hours before this incidient, that gave plenty of time for a proper evacuation. Like normal it is all about profit than common sense and safety.
I do not disagree that the workers of the zoo care about he animals, it is just apparent that they are not qualified to handle large animals. Please stick to ones that you can properly take care of.
September 9, 2011 at 2:40 pm
Anonymous
I want zoo america to admit there wrong doing! step up and admit that their slow and hesitant reaction to a very serious and very warned disaster is the reason these bison are dead! and the prairie dogs i assume as well. I give NO SYMPATHY to the staff. the position they were placed in was the consequence to their mistakes.
September 9, 2011 at 2:46 pm
Elizabeth
you know what, i’m soooo tired of people bashing on Hershey about trying to save animals…they saved about 99% of them. I hate that two bison had died, but that’s not the zoo’s fault. I agree that it was a terrible loss, and i’m upset by it, seeing as to how i work at the park! It effects me too, i love animals. i have dogs and i’m going to college for marine science. that obviously doesn’t mean that i don’t care about other animals, because i do, most of the time when i go to hershey park, i always go to the zoo. I love the zoo, and have never been disappointed by it either. I am however disappointed that all of you people on here that are bashing on Hershey, you don’t put your names on your posts, that’s cowardly, and i for one, am disappointed that you all think it’s so easy to just pack up an animal that isn’t used to coming into too much contact with humans, and move them to a different environment. I will always endorse zooamerica and i believe they did everything they could to save their animals. I’m sure they all have very tight bonds with the animals and that it was such a terrible loss for them to lose to very beautiful animals. not shame on hershey, shame on everybody whose bashing on hershey.
September 9, 2011 at 2:47 pm
savetheanimals
Dear Stupid, you are horrible people . The bison don’t want to be in your awful zoo in the first place and your incompetance lead to their death. Its a tragedy they were imprisoned, its a crime they had to be shot. Stop equivocating and admit your failure to plan effectively. I am amazed that you claim to respect and feel sorrow for the animals while having imprisoned them in the first place. You are simply a moneymaking enterprise that prospers off of the misery of wild animals.
September 9, 2011 at 2:56 pm
Kate
This whole event,no matter the circumstances, was tragic I can only hope that something positive comes out of it. Hopefully a better evac plan will be made or even a change to how or where the bison are located. Weather is unpredicable and I do not blame the actual zoo keepers, I just want to see that maybe something was learned from this mess.
September 9, 2011 at 3:00 pm
Anonymous
“Q: Were the bison moved to higher ground?
A: Yes. They were moved to the highest ground within their enclosure earlier in the week.”
WHAT HIGHEST GROUND?! that pen the flattest in the zoo
no one is blaming the employees, but the people in charge need to take the blame!
i cannot believe the neglect and hesitation that was displayed.
if an child is having a fit, you calm it down! not shoot it
if a bison is scared and unable to be walked out, you sedate it
GET IT!
“When the bison enclosure flooded so quickly, tranquilizing them become impossible, for once they were tranquilized they would have immediately been submerged in the flood water and drown”
it wasnt a flash flood! the water flowed in, it didnt go from 0 to 6 feet i saw it, my family saw it. there was time from when the water first started to flow in to the second they SHOT those animals. there was plenty of time to sedate and remove those amazing animals while the water was mere inches this it the most PATHETIC excuse ive ever heard. “if we tranquilize them they would have submerged” NOT IF YOU WOULD HAVE TAKEN ACTION! the death of these animals is a tragedy an act of murder by neglect.
i hope the people responsible for such passive behavior towards these lives are held RESPONSIBLE and corrective action takes place.
September 9, 2011 at 3:12 pm
Michelle
elizabeth, these deaths were preventable!
in what why is it okay for a company to get away with killing animals.
there was HOURS of notice before the flooding.
there was plenty of time to save all the animals and yet there was still fatalities.
your desensitized if you believe that these deaths were justified.
September 9, 2011 at 3:29 pm
Exasperated
Dear Elizabeth, You are one of the few who is actually making sense on this site.
Dear Herhsey Bashers,
I’ve said it earlier and will repeat it since you refuse to unclutter your minds from Villifying Zoo America: OFCOURSE the deaths were preventable…so were the human lives lost. As the saying goes: hind-sight really is 20/20.
What is infuriating right now are the relentless ignorant comments against Hershey. Sure, I am mad that they weren’t able to save them but what good is it to continually take their focus off of rebuilding / repairing the zoo for the rest of the animals that they have protected.
LAY OFF!!!!! If you are so concerned about animals then there is something you CAN do: (a few things) A) Chill out and let the focus be on things now within control. Rebuilding / and checking in to see how the habitat is for the animals NOW. Remember, this isn’t cleared out yet B) Get off your bums and ask what can be done C) Put your energy into encouraging, supporting and HELPING instead of standing on the sidelines and doing NOTHING but complaining. D) Open your minds a little and understand that what is done is done and all that you are doing is making bad to worse
September 9, 2011 at 3:38 pm
AlyceAnn Jula Aber
WHAT about all the other animals?? Lets stop harping on what the zoo will ADMIT to and lets hear about the rest of them!!
September 9, 2011 at 3:51 pm
Lisa K.
i will not over look the death of any life. is sad to see that some can. and as far as ‘hershey bashing’ goes how mundane.
it is outrageous this happened. no one if forgetting the animals who were safe. no one is wanting to hold up repairs to the facility.
September 9, 2011 at 4:10 pm
Diann Showers
I am so upset about the loss because The question on everyone’s mind is why were these animals not moved late Sunday early Monday morning. The warnings were issued. While we all understand the size and weight of these animals then it makes sense to everyone that they being in the lowest part of the zoo should have been gotten out along with the rest. I dint have to be a specialist to know these guys would have probably taken the longest to move ergo act early. That didn’t happen. They were left there. I want to know where this higher ground is. I’ve been there plenty of times and I don’t recall any such area in the enclosure. Zoo America wants to talk about events after the fact. Most of us who are angered are so because no steps were taken to remove them when the first warnings came over the airwaves.
ALOT of us have lived here all our lives and
Hershey is a part of all of us. I spent an entire
summer at about age 9 maybe helping to feed the animals on a daily basis, as my babysitter
got a job in the zoo and took me along. So
before we are judged please understand that
any able bodied person would have came to Zoo
Americas aide had they bothered to ask.
Pitching in to help save what is important to t
he communities it affects. My daughter who is 27 remembers both bison was extremely angry when ibtold her. Sounds crazy but our kids
basically grew up with them. Hershey can’t see
past te dollar signs anymore. It probably doesn’t makeba difference to corporate America but the community lost something we can’t get back., andbit could have Bren prevented
make a difference how we feel. We just believe starting with the very first warnings they all should have been moved from the bottom up.
September 9, 2011 at 4:11 pm
Anonymous
@Anonymous: To all of the naysayers out there,
Yes, in fact there were people there days and hours leading up to this.
This pasted from Anonymous (September 9 2011 at 3pm.)
“it wasn’t a flash flood! the water flowed in, it didn’t go from 0 to 6 feet i saw it, my family saw it. there was time from when the water first started to flow in to the second they SHOT those animals. there was plenty of time to sedate and remove those amazing animals while the water was mere inches this it the most PATHETIC excuse Ive ever heard. ”
Due to social media..I have seen the pictures myself, and Zoo America Has fed us all a load of crap!
@Elizabeth
“You don’t put your name on your post, that’s cowardly”
Maybe this is because they live right near (about 100 ft) from Zoo America..and trust me..a few people in this town, next door has and will continue to let Zoo America they were wrong.
There were 2 people trying to get these Bison out of harms way! TWO!
Again TWO! And 2 Bison died.
2 people..to get 2 Bison out of harms way..this does not make any sense.
Shame on you Zoo America!!!
September 9, 2011 at 4:12 pm
Diann Showers
Why did you open that day?
September 9, 2011 at 4:42 pm
Lisa Dalto
My prayers are with your staff during this sad time. I am certain that the best decisions were made under extraordinary circumstances. It is a great loss at the zoo and I’m sure you have so many things to care for in the aftermath of the flooding. I appreciate the additional information you shared and I hope you know that so many people support you and are saddened by the loss you must feel. If you decide to allow community volunteers to help with the cleanup I would be glad to lend a hand.
September 9, 2011 at 4:55 pm
Amy
People are so quick to try to inflict their point of view after the fact. In this society of free speech and lawsuits, ignorance and insults run rampant.
May God bless all of you at the Zoo. You have to love the animals to work there and they become family. We have seen the worst weather events in history in places that couldn’t have imagined such atrocity. Many people ran outside when they felt the earthquake. It was the wrong thing to do because our preparedness did not account for it. I hope that the weather events get better but we all know that wont happen. So all we can do is prepare better for the next event. You had to make a decision at that moment. It is one you must live with forever. How dare people undermine this tragedy. Again, may God bless you all.
September 9, 2011 at 4:58 pm
Anonymous
very small neighborhood.
these bison were in the lowest part of the zoo, and one of, if not the largest animals there. the most logical thing to do would have been remove them first. there were only 2 people even there attempting to move the bison, TWO!
they were told monday that they should move the bison.
theres a facebook page made “remembering the zoo america bison”
its a joke. People who are actually upset over this tragedy wanting to show their grief and disappointment getting badgered for caring about something.
how sad is it that when animals die out of pure neglect that showing compassion can be mocked.
September 9, 2011 at 5:00 pm
Anonymous
In reply to this statement from an earlier post:
“I have to ask the person verbally attacking the zoo and it’s staff on here, will you do the same to the people who got caught off gaurd by the flooding and how fast it took many areas if the same were to happen to them.”
If a person is caught off guard in an area prone to flash flooding, they have made a conscious choice to be there. These animals relied upon people to make that decision for them and it was a poor decision that cost them their lives.
September 9, 2011 at 5:10 pm
Anonymous
why are people continuing to act like everyone whos upset about the death of the bison is blaming all the staff?
seriously? of course the teenagers running the gift shop and tour guides should be left be, but to act like the people in the big office should feel pressured by people for making a HUGE mistake?
i give them NO sympathy and am glad they will live knowing they caused the murder of 2 iconic creatures.
feel bad for the people who decided to kill the bison?
i think not, their still alive and because ‘they didnt know’ it was going to get that bad and didnt take action they have to live with that.
September 9, 2011 at 5:12 pm
Kathy K- Middletown, PA
From videos of roads and bridges washing away so quickly I am sure that the staff did everything they could do for all the animals. It must have been so heartwrenching for them and I commend them for everything they did- even risking their own lives. When you think about the staff ratio to the number of animals in there …I’m sure during this flooding they did the very best they could. To the people out there complaining – Where were you ? Perhaps worrying about your properties, trying to get your kids home from school, or running around shooting pics and videos when emergency crews were asking everyone to stay home in order to avoid more tragedies. Face it, it’s been a sad day all around …no matter how you look at it.
September 9, 2011 at 5:16 pm
Anonymous
ITS WASNT A FLASH FLOOD!! GET IT!!!
it fell in inches not feet.
they had days of warnings!!
they did nothing.
they did all they could do, once the neglected to do something sooner.
dont pity the people who euthanized the bison
grieve for the loss of 2 majestic lifes lost because a greedy zoo could go a day with out the bison.
September 9, 2011 at 5:20 pm
Jennifer C.
I wish all the folks who are bashing Hershey/ZooAmerica for not taking the appropriate actions and for not knowing that they were going to be hit with a flood, less alone an unprecendented amount of flooding, would tell me which lottery numbers to pick for tomorrow night because if you are one of them (pick one), you a. know it all; b. have a crystal ball that apparently no one else has; c. are God.
For the folks who are screaming about calling PETA – what were they going to do? Start a petition to stop flooding?
My condolences to everyone at ZooAmerica. My thoughts and prayers are with you.
September 9, 2011 at 5:30 pm
Anonymous
I am very upset at the staff of ZooAmerica. You obviously are not prepared to handle such events. I’ve been to the Zoo several times. You do not have enough “safe havens” in the Zoo when events, such as this flood, happen.
Where are you keeping the other animals? When did you move the other animals? What animals did you move? Why did you leave the bison out of their pen when they are so close to the water? I’m curious to hear some of these answers.
Where were you when the bison exhibit was filling with water? Who took the picture of the poor bison drowning? Please feel free to answer my questions at anytime – I’d really like to hear from Troy Stump and Dale Snyder (mgmt at the Zoo).
Thank you!
September 9, 2011 at 5:32 pm
Anonymous
I am very upset at the staff of ZooAmerica. You obviously are not prepared to handle such events. I’ve been to the Zoo several times. You do not have enough “safe havens” in the Zoo when events, such as this flood, happen.
Where are you keeping the other animals? When did you move the other animals? What animals did you move? Why did you leave the bison in their pen when they are so close to the water? I’m curious to hear some of these answers.
Where were you when the bison exhibit was filling with water? Who took the picture of the poor bison drowning? Please feel free to answer my questions at anytime – I’d really like to hear from Troy Stump and Dale Snyder (mgmt at the Zoo).
Thank you!
September 9, 2011 at 5:33 pm
Anonymous
Why did you leave the bison in their pen when they are so close to the water?***
September 9, 2011 at 6:01 pm
Exasperated
Will the answers to your questions really make a difference? make you feel better? restore the lives of the bison????
September 9, 2011 at 6:23 pm
Anonymous
Actually, yes, it will make me feel better, thank you
September 9, 2011 at 6:29 pm
carolecoulson889
Thank you for clearing up questions! I’m glad to hear that the death of wolves was just a rumor. I am, of course, saddened by the death of the bison. I would only blame the people who approved, those many years ago, the design plan that had such low lying places this close to the creek. But of course no one could foresee how high it was going to get. I know the job turnover there is very small because of the dedication of the zoo workers and their attachment to their animals. My heart goes out to the bison caretakers. I know you did what you could with the emergency plan in place and unlike others, I feel compassion for your loss and not anger at you or anyone there.
September 9, 2011 at 6:37 pm
Anonymous
If that makes you feel better, then that just goes to show how petty and bitter you are. I’m sure management has a lot more pressing concerns than to answer to the general public on issues that have already been sufficiently addressed!
September 9, 2011 at 6:41 pm
Lindsey Bicksler
Regardless of what could or couldn’t have been done during the storm, the keepers care very much about each of these animals and are just as upset right now. They literally lost their family members. We are zooamericas neighbors and instead of pointing fingers we should be supporting them. I would hope you would do the same if a human neighbor lost a family member, no matter how they may have died.
September 9, 2011 at 6:47 pm
Anonymous
Is it true that the creek was re-routed or slowed due to new ride construction that more than likely made flooding worse than expected?
September 9, 2011 at 6:56 pm
scargosun
Absolutely no excuse. There were weather reports for days and days preceding the flooding. There was nowhere for any more water to go. You KILLED not euthanized animals because of poor planning. Bottom line. Your ‘zoo’ took on the responsibility of caring for those animals when they came to you and you decided it was just too much to do to try to save them. It’s called being reactive instead of proactive. Most greedy companies suffer from that these days. They weigh profit against loss of ‘attractions’. I guess the bison were just collateral damage. Lovely. Hershey is already showing its dark side with the abuse of overseas students being highlighted, this is just one more nail in the coffin for them. I hope that even more people will boycott the company now.
September 9, 2011 at 6:58 pm
Anonymous
no, questions have not been sufficiently answered. are you kidding?
are you kidding? of course wanting answers wont make the bison come alive, but it will bring notice to the lack of total control of the situation.
what you feel bad because your friend works there?your co workers daughters boyfriends cousin checks stamps so you feel you have to defend it. dont be a child,
and jennifer c, seriously? crystal ball, petition to stop flooding, are you that dense. my 6 year old niece can understand that it you leave the biggest animals in the lowest lying cage to be removed once theres already 4 feet of water in there something went wrong.
your missing the point. they had 2 days notice to move them, they had 2 hour plus once water was actually getting into the bison pen and they only had 2 people attempting to move 2 2,000lb bison. theyr making excuses, and if someone decides to call peta or any other animal activist groups then props to them, maybe someone can help these quacks develop a better evac plan and not cause anymore lives to be expended,
i cant believe how ignorant people can be. id like to see you in a bowl of muddy water helps less after people warned you about the dangers that could come..the bison were entrusted to a billion dollar company, and the only cent spent was on a gun for execution instead of avoiding a situation like this, no not a situation, a tragedy.
September 9, 2011 at 7:07 pm
GreatJobHershey
Zoo America shouldn’t exist in the first place. Stick with chocolate…oh wait, you’re moving those operations to Mexico, aren’t you? Ok…stick with amusement parks and leave the animals alone.
September 9, 2011 at 7:07 pm
Exasperated
We’re the ignorant ones? The ones’ that hope the lesson is learned and want to move on rather than ask redundent questions that really lead no-where other than right back to; 2 bison tragically died.
But, I guess I am too dense to understand that dwelling on a situation won’t change it. And don’t fool yourself to think that Hershey isn’t already evaluating and reporting their evac plan to the boards that they are accredited to.
Hard to reason with a person who thinks my motivation is: “what you feel bad because your friend works there?your co workers daughters boyfriends cousin checks stamps so you feel you have to defend it. dont be a child,”
September 9, 2011 at 7:08 pm
Angela
Perhaps having a zoo in a flood prone area isn’t a great idea?! I’m new to the area, but it sounds like this is not the first time there has been flooding at this location. Maybe this event should trigger a relocation plan instead of a flood plan.
September 9, 2011 at 7:16 pm
Maggie Mae Funkhouser
I am very disappointed with the way Zoo America handled this situation. Obviously, this was “unprecedented flooding” but isn’t that what your action plan is for…so you have a plan if a situation like this occurs? You could clearly see that the water was continuing to rise, that perhaps it was time to implement plan B and move the animals! Why did you wait until the water was up to their necks, when it was too late, to handle the situation?!
It all comes down to money. It was cheaper for you to kill the animals than to implement a plan of action to actually move them to a safer place. No one wants to hear the excuses. If proper plans were in place, this would not have happened. I agree with another commenter, that Hershey should stick to the amusement park side of things and leave animals out of it, because obviously they are not in good hands.
September 9, 2011 at 7:23 pm
Anonymous
exasperated i hope you have exasperated your opinion.. if your so fed up with people expressing their grief and anger maybe you should stop reading something that just perpetually pisses you off.
talk about circle, posting upset you? maybe you should see if theres anymore upsetting posting an hour later.
zoo america was to small and poorly placed.
and as far as would i be upset with my human neighbors? hell yes if someone died du to negligence after multiple warning to get prepared, of course i would be just as upset and disappointed. AND there would be re precautions.
which im still hoping there will also be re precautions for the administrator who allowed this to happen…pure negligence
September 9, 2011 at 7:25 pm
Anonymous
money talks, and we must talk louder for the sake of the animals
September 9, 2011 at 7:34 pm
The Reverent
To “Exasperated”
When a human being claims stewardship over one of or many of God’s creatures: than we become responsible for their wellbeing. The Hershey Corporation built the Zoo, Maintains the Zoo, Pays for the Zoo, and employs the Zoo.
Let’s keep our eyes on the ball shall we, It is the operational structure; not the Zoo employees that determine what and if the animals are to be moved. It has already been reported that this was a progressive flood, and I live in New Hampshire and have relatives in Vermont; and we know what it means to be in a “progressive Flood state of an emergency”.
Hershey is a multi- billion dollar a year enterprise, whose theme park is the cherry on top of its huge wealth obtaining “Money Machine Sunday”. The Zoo is nothing more than a profit center, used to bring in revenue, just like Chocolate world, the Hershey Museum, and other theme park and resort attractions.
My family and I visited Hershey a little over three weeks ago, and in our eight day visit went to the so called “zoo”. I have video and pictures of the whole zoo and those two Bison; and let me tell you, after looking at this so called zoo, I am disgusted with the events that have happened.
There was no higher ground for the two bison; the whole holding pen was like a huge bowl with a small tributary running through it, and I have the video and pictures to prove it . The black bear, prairie dogs, white tail deer were all down there also; what happened to them?
The real fact is, that Hershey did not want to close its profit center until the last minute; after all they are only “living assets” , possibly fully insured. These poor animals depended on humans to feed and take care of them; the Hershey Corporation Failed in their stewardship responsibilities horribly.
I do not blame the Zoo division employees, I blame the corporate management; there have been many instances were zoos have had to move animals because of natural disasters. I have seen the forest service save Coyotes on ice sheet in Massachusetts in the spring melt, never mind a Zoo.
This is disgusting and predictable, Hershey is to blame, for the mistreatment of those animals; stop defending them and shifting blame
September 9, 2011 at 7:51 pm
Anonymous
FYI PEOPLE – HERSHEYPARK AND THE HERSHEY COMPANY (CHOCOLATE MAKERS) ARE TWO SEPARATE ENTITIES.
GET YOUR FACTS TOGETHER BEFORE YOU GO SPOUTING OFF!!
THIS IS ABOUT ZOOAMERICA – NOT FOREIGN KIDS, MEXICO OR CHOCOLATE.
THANKS!
September 9, 2011 at 8:03 pm
The Reverent
“September 9, 2011 at 7:51 pm
“Anonymous
FYI PEOPLE – HERSHEYPARK AND THE HERSHEY COMPANY (CHOCOLATE MAKERS) ARE TWO SEPARATE ENTITIES.
GET YOUR FACTS TOGETHER BEFORE YOU GO SPOUTING OFF!!
THIS IS ABOUT ZOOAMERICA – NOT FOREIGN KIDS, MEXICO OR CHOCOLATE.
“THANKS!”
To Anonymons: just thought you should know:
The park is run by Hershey Entertainment Group, a division of Hershey Entertainment and Resorts Company. Hershey Entertainment and Resorts Company owns the park, and is in turn wholly owned by the Hershey Trust Company. Within the Trust’s holdings, Hershey Entertainment and Resorts Company is part of the Milton Hershey School Trust.
In 1975 John Strawbridge was serving as a director for the Hershey Museum, and convinced Hershey Estates to invest in redeveloping the old zoo as a themed zoological park: ZooAmerica.
I guess our facts are straight. Thank you for your concern.
September 9, 2011 at 8:08 pm
The Reverent
And just so that we are clear:
The company was originally founded by Milton S. Hershey as part of his chocolate company: what is now Hersheypark was initially promoted by including a picture postcard in each box of chocolate bars.
In 1927, Hershey split his enterprises into three companies, Hershey Chocolate Corporation which he took public, Hershey Corporation, which acquired the sugar estates in Cuba, and Hershey Estates.[2]
The childless Hershey had previously founded a trust in 1909 to establish the Hershey Industrial School for orphan boys, later renamed the Milton Hershey School. The Hershey Trust inherited Hershey Estates, Hershey Corporation, and a majority of the voting stock in Hershey Chocolate Corporation. The sugar operations in Cuba were sold in 1947 to the Cuban Atlantic Sugar Corporation.[3] Hershey Chocolate changed its name to Hershey Foods Corp in 1968,[4] and in 2005, to the The Hershey Company.[5]
September 9, 2011 at 8:14 pm
Anonymous
To: “The Reverent”
You are 100% WRONG. The Hershey Company is NOT the same as Hershey Entertainment & Resorts. Look it up – do your research!
The Hershey Company owns the chocolate plants (all over the US) and Chocolate World (in Hershey) whereas Hershey Entertainment & Resorts owns Hersheypark, ZooAmerica, The Hershey Hotel, The Lodge, The Campground, The Hershey Story, several restaraunts, etc.
The Hershey Trust Company is a private trust company founded by Milton S. Hershey in 1905. Hershey Trust Company is wholly owned by the Milton Hershey School Trust, for which Hershey Trust Company is Trustee. In 1909, Milton Hershey created the Milton Hershey School and School Trust and appointed Hershey Trust Company as Trustee of the School Trust. Mr. Hershey established the Milton Hershey School and School Trust to provide full-time education and care for disadvantaged children in perpetuity. The School’s original enrollment was 10 students. Today, over 100 years later, Mr. Hershey’s legacy continues. The School currently has an enrollment of more than 1,800 students, with an equal mix of boys and girls. Enrollment is expected to grow to 2,000 students in coming years.
Got it now?!
September 9, 2011 at 8:21 pm
Anonymous
The Hershey Company, known until April 2005 as the Hershey Foods Corporation[3] and commonly called Hershey’s, is the largest chocolate manufacturer in North America.[4] Its headquarters are in Hershey, Pennsylvania, which is also home to Hershey’s Chocolate World. It was founded by Milton S. Hershey in 1894 as the Hershey Chocolate Company, a subsidiary of his Lancaster Caramel Company. Hershey’s products are sold in about sixty countries worldwide.[5][4]
Hershey is one of the oldest chocolate companies in the United States, and an American icon for its chocolate bar. It is one of a group of companies established by Milton Hershey. Other Milton Hershey-established companies include Hershey Trust Company, and Hershey Entertainment and Resorts Company, which runs Hersheypark, a chocolate-themed amusement park, the Hershey Bears minor professional hockey team, Hersheypark Stadium and the GIANT Center. Most of the employees for the factory come from the surrounding counties, towns, and boroughs, such as Lebanon County, Hummelstown, South Hanover, and Harrisburg. Hershey’s labor practices and its failure to adopt fair trade policies to has made the company a target of criticism.
—————————————————
Hershey Trust Company was created in 1905, as Milton S. Hershey was organized to create the Milton Hershey School. In 1909, when he founded the school, Hershey appointed the Trust as administrator of the school trust. When Milton Hershey died in 1945, Hershey Estates (renamed Hershey Entertainment and Resorts Company) came under Hershey Trust administration.
—————————————————-
Hershey Entertainment and Resorts (‘HE&R’[1]), also known as “HERCO”, is a privately owned company of the Hershey Trust Company.
The company was originally founded by Milton S. Hershey as part of his chocolate company: what is now Hersheypark was initially promoted by including a picture postcard in each box of chocolate bars.
In 1927, Hershey split his enterprises into three companies, Hershey Chocolate Corporation which he took public, Hershey Corporation, which acquired the sugar estates in Cuba, and Hershey Estates.[2]
The childless Hershey had previously founded a trust in 1909 to establish the Hershey Industrial School for orphan boys, later renamed the Milton Hershey School. The Hershey Trust inherited Hershey Estates, Hershey Corporation, and a majority of the voting stock in Hershey Chocolate Corporation. The sugar operations in Cuba were sold in 1947 to the Cuban Atlantic Sugar Corporation.[3] Hershey Chocolate changed its name to Hershey Foods Corp in 1968,[4] and in 2005, to the The Hershey Company.[5]
The “Hershey Dairy” in that listing should not be confused with Hershey’s Creamery, the manufacturers of Hershey Ice Cream. The creamery was founded in 1894 by Jacob N. Hershey, whose family was unrelated to Milton Hershey.
In 1976, the company changed its name from Hershey Estates to HERCO, Inc. and then in 1980 to Hershey Entertainment and Resorts, Inc.[2]
September 9, 2011 at 8:35 pm
SamIamNH
I have a picture and video that was taken a few weeks ago at Hershey Park Zoo America of these bison.. There was no place for these poor animals to go when the flood waters came, Hershey choose to stay open while churches and schools closed for the dangerous conditions. There is NO higher ground, so whatever Hershey is saying is false, the animals drown (actually were shot) right in this display case they were kept in. As we visited this place, my husband and I thought this was not a zoo but a display case for animals. It was 100 degrees that day and no place for the animals to get shade. Hershey’s official statement is only 2 animals are dead, but neighbors who share a property line with this “ZOO” say they heard the other animals crying out for hours!! ASPCA please come investigate!! I will be nothing less than shocked when the flood waters go and that more animals are not dead for the sake of profit to the last dime. The Lord trusts us to take care of His creatures, shame on you!! TThe flood waters came too quick, Mr. Hershey would be disgusted!!!
September 9, 2011 at 8:39 pm
SamIamNH
I would love to be a fly on the wall with the meetings of Hershey executives with their risk management team!! FYI!! Many of your neighbors have pictures and videos of what was really going on ( why do you think the tarps went up!!)
September 9, 2011 at 9:13 pm
SamIamNH
I am curious “Anonymous” what is your stake in all this?
September 9, 2011 at 9:16 pm
Anonymous
In this day when we can track a storm to a specific street practically, it is not plausible that everything was done to save the bison. They should have been moved–whoever made the decision to not move them earlier could never work for me. ALWAYS take the side of caution! It’s a real shame. I do feel badly for the “in the trenches” every day hard working keepers who probably had no say in the decision making process.
September 9, 2011 at 9:42 pm
Crystal Friend
I have been to ZooAmerica and all of the staff always wonderful. I am sure that an establishment like this did everything they could to prepare and remove the animals. It is easy for people to comment from the outside and talk about all the things that “should” have been done but lets be honest, in chaos and catastrophe all that planning goes right out the window! There is never a plan good enough for the “what ifs”! Zoo America I am sorry for your loss and look forward to our annual visit this fall when things can reopen!
September 9, 2011 at 9:43 pm
Kristen Michaelson
Our thoughts and prayers are with the team at Zoo America. My family lives in downtown Hershey and has spent many wonderful days enjoying the animals. My children keep asking about the Praire Dogs and Louie the Inguana, who is usually kept in one of the shops near the entrance of the park. If you have a moment to post something over the next few days, we would appreciate hearing how they are doing. Please take care of yourselves during this difficult period.
September 9, 2011 at 9:45 pm
Barbara
I am very sadden for your losses. Are you going to get more Bison? I love all the animals. I m very proud of all staff for getting the animals out of harms way. Is there any way of getting the enclosures raised higher to keep flooding out?
September 9, 2011 at 10:00 pm
Anonymous
As a former member of Hersheypark Safety & Security, I’ve seen the park flood during a summer storm. Hersheypark and ZooAmerica are bad flood spots and you can’t account for every weather event. This storm came up so fast, and while you anonymous people berate the zooamerica staff on a blog in your nice internet connect homes, EMS and Fire Departments around Lebanon, Derry, and the rest of Central PA are still scrambling to keep everyone safe. In fact 3 people have died from this storm. Get your priorities straight first off, and secondly I know ZooAmerica exhausted their options prior to making this decision, so to all you anonymous whiners….either come out here and help us clean up and recover our area….or STFU. I feel very sad for the Bison, and I’m sorry it happened, but there’s worse things STILL happening that need attention.
September 9, 2011 at 10:01 pm
leonna l
Yes please answer….
WHAT HAPPEN TO THE PRAIRIE DOGS???
September 9, 2011 at 10:10 pm
Anonymous
anonymous now i know why your a FORMER employee!
September 9, 2011 at 10:14 pm
Anonymous
OMG! How many times do I have to tell you people – there is no damn conspiracy theory! There is complete transparency coming from the company, not like anyone is owed that transparency with the this deplorable attitude towards the zoo. The two bison were the ONLY animals to perish, and this was because of the amazingly fast and courageous actions of zoo staff! The people who claim more died are just sensationalizing the story to shift focus on themselves. Pathetic really. Enough with the second guessing. What’s done is done. Quit trying to psycgologically terrorize others.
September 9, 2011 at 10:15 pm
Anonymous
I felt bad for Zoo America until I learned it was opened that day until noon. With days of warning and history of flooding in that enclosure what they did to those bison is inexcusable. Some one needs to be held responsible for this. Steve Irwin would be pissed!
September 9, 2011 at 10:40 pm
Anonymous
im sooo tired of hearing they did everything possible
no obviously not or the bison wouldnt have still been in there
the storm DID NOT come out of no where, it was warned for days to keep the animals safe
if you have else to say, look past your blindness of your personal involvement..
September 9, 2011 at 10:46 pm
Mindy Shepler
I’m so sorry for the loss of the bison and any other animals who did not make it out.
No one could have foreseen just how bad it was going to get. I know the staff did everything in their power to save every animal that they could. My heart goes out to the animals and the staff of the zoo who tried all they could. Flash Flooding is exactly that FLASH FLOODING. Yes we knew that thei storm could bring epic amounts of rainfall, but not one of us could have foreseen just how fast and how much was going to fall in just a short period of time. It took me by surprise as well. My neighbor has lived in his home since the 50′s and he told me that this is the worst he’s seen since 1975. I helped my neighbors around the bend evacuate their home and although the water stopped before flooding their home and garage, I was shocked at how fast it rose. I will continue to support ZooAmerica and what they do for the animals there. I will one day make it out there again to visit my wolves.
September 9, 2011 at 11:27 pm
Anonymous
This was no freak storm. Any one could have looked at the radar maps on weather.com and seen it was one long train of rain moving north. The zoo never should have opened that day. You have animals in a cage next to a stream in the lowest part of the zoo. With the advanced warning they had plenty of time to insure the safety of the animals and chose profit instead.
September 10, 2011 at 12:11 am
Anonymous
to the person that has no life and can comment at 4AM Irregardless is not a word. we recieved one inch of rain in 45 minutes and watched a wall of water move across a field today. when something bad occurs in the world it doesn’t always have to be somebodys fault. what about all the animals the die in a brutal manner in the wild, whos fault is it then? Nature? Just because they are in captivity doesn’t mean they can be fully protected just as people that perish in such events. Hind sight is 20/20 the water Hershey nearly doubled its record crest. Bottom line….ITS NOBODYS FAULT! NO ABUSE, NO NEGLECT! Romans 8:28
September 10, 2011 at 12:20 am
Debbie
It is amazing to me how hateful so many of these posts are. My family has lives in the Hershey/Hummelstown area for decades and there has been flooding. From all the reports I have seen they were looking at flood waters over 20 feet high in a few hours. I believe Ivans flooding was at 16 feet and that was the worst in recent history. I am sure the zoo was prepared for flooding to those levels but never planned or expected the flooding they got the other day. should they have planned for something this bad, maybe. Were they under-prepared, maybe. Are the negligent or criminal, certainly not. It was very tragic and hopefully zoos around the nation will learn from this and be better prepared for the unexpected.
September 10, 2011 at 12:50 am
Anna Marie Tucker
Milton Hershey is probably groaning and rolling in his grave over what his legacy has become.
However, so many people make so many comments that sound ridiculous. The fact that people can refer to coyotes crying is proof that they have not actually been to the zoo or know the sounds a coyote makes.
The person that posted the bison could have been loaded into a horse trailer made me made me laugh out loud! I wonder if these same people who keep criticizing the zoo and making claims the animals were not properly cared for having any kind of credentials in dealing with wild animals or how many volunteer hours they have put in AND where they get their information on how the zoo takes care of animals.
It can be argued that the idea of a zoo is wrong. However, since I patronize zoos and animal parks such as lake tobias and enjoy experiencing things I would not be able to expose my children to otherwise when things are great and fun…cannot turn around when things go bac and say the zoois bad. I have enjoyed the zoo, its programs and learned many things. It is tragic this happened, but I understand how it could. After all, I sent my child to school on a bus and he was trapped on it for an hour. Would that we all consulted our crystal balls that morning.
I would be interested to know how the prairie dogs were evacuated. I know the layout of the zoo well, and it seems they were vulernable. The wolves were higher up and had rocks and things to climb even higher.
It is always easy for those sitting warm and happy to criticize those who have their sleeves rolled up doing the work. It is an age old battle. The “doers’ and the “complainers”.
September 10, 2011 at 12:58 am
Kathy K- Middletown, PA
Way to go Debbie ! This world is becoming more and more hateful….perhaps God is sending us messages….but the hateful people can’t read between the lines !
September 10, 2011 at 2:31 am
Chad Dietrick, Hummelstown, PA
Q If and when you decied to to have Bison again. Where are they going to be transported from and how?
September 10, 2011 at 2:52 am
Zoo Supporter
Picture this if you will: You are someone who consistently pays attention to the seven day weather forecast. In this particular forecast for the week ahead you see there is a 100% of rain with the possibility of a scattered thunderstorm every day. So, you go about your business just like any other day. The sun is out one minute when suddenly one of those scattered thunderstorms you have been so used to dealing with ALL your life suddenly appears out of nowhere, but this time you are struck by a bolt of lightening and die instantly.
Question: Then is it YOUR fault because you should have known ahead of time you would be struck by lightening?? After all, you “knew” there was a chance of scattered thunderstorms every day, but YOU didn’t take precautions ahead of time and should have known Mother Nature would suddenly cast a bolt of lightening upon you…..it was just one of those TYPICAL “scattered thunderstorms”…Right???
This particular situation is no different than the flash flood people! If the zoo staff should have “known better, should have done things differently” and all the other hoopla you people claim should have taken place, than it is expected YOU too should have known better and would be expected to have reacted accordingly…and YOU would still be alive!
I think all the people who have posted hateful messages blasting Zoo America really DO need to stop and think! This storm was of epic historical proportions! NO ONE could predict the water would rise that quickly in such a short amount of time. I guess those people whose homes were severely flooded and lost everything within a matter of minutes “should have known better” even though it was supposed to be just “another flash flood”, one of MANY flash floods we have experienced throughout our lifetime and nothing quite to this degree had ever happened to us before. At least not since the Agnes flood of 1972….Thirty-nine years ago! After a catastrophic situation occurs it usually means there was not enough time to prepare for it before you were forced to evacuate the premises. Because had you known ahead of time you would have picked up your house and moved it directly out of harms way…..Right??? So, if you honestly think for one minute the zoo staff intended for this to happen, you are CRAZY!!!
And as for the people who are in such an uproar about the placing of tarps around where the bison drowned….I suppose you are the same idiots who drive past an accident scene where there is a fatality and they put up a blue tarp out of respect for the victim AND to keep the general public from having to witness something so horrific….Next time you see an auto accident with a fatality and one of those blue tarps go up, stop and tell the emergency personal to take it down because YOU think it is wrong to protect the dignity and privacy of the person who died….see how far you get before they call out the white coats to come haul your idiotic self away from the scene.
Those bison deserved the same dignity, privacy and respect as any other living creature, and as far as I am concerned the zoo staff did EVERYTHING within their power and all you negative people with such perfect lives need to get a damn life and stop criticizing the actions of others!!! If you could have done a better job yourself, why weren’t YOU there to help move those bison and the other animals when the rain began and the flash flood warnings were initially announced?? Probably because you had “better” things to do, like sitting in front of your computer screen at home in a dry environment waiting for something to complain about! Ah, the ignorance of the KNOW-IT-ALLS and NAY SAYERS shall never cease to amaze the rest of us!
September 10, 2011 at 2:57 am
anonymous
I’ve read most of these comments with extreme interest. All zoos, aquariums and museums must have a disaster plan. It appears that ZooAmerica has a flood plan which is probably a part of their disaster plan. I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt.
However, each part of the disaster plan is to start with the worst case scenario. If moving the animals to the highest part of their territory is considered the worst case scenario, it is my hope that ZooAmerica’s flood plan protocols are changed. Hindsight is always 20/20 but in this case, much can be learned and changed
September 10, 2011 at 3:03 am
Anonymous
Just want to send our support to all of those at ZooAmerica. We are saddened by the loss, and we will keep you in our prayers. Thank you for letting us know what really happened. Thank you for all of your work to save our animals. I look forward to our return to the zoo. Know that many are with you and applaud your efforts, I am sure it was a dreadful day for all.
September 10, 2011 at 3:29 am
Anonymous
Can you describe the inclosure these bison were in? The “pen” I remember was along the creek’s edge and was flat. People walked from above (between the elk and the bison – see the last known picture of the bison online or in the news). Is there a way you can make an on-sight emergency facility for those who have inclosures that are in more flood-proned areas? Does one already exist?
RIP Bison Esther and Ryan.
September 10, 2011 at 3:30 am
Anonymous
How about the prairie dogs?
Is drowning worse then being shot by the hand that feeds you while you are caged?
As a hunter, I know that it would take a hefty bullet and a perfect accuracy to harvest a bison with one shot. Chances are the shooter while standing in chest high water, took a pot shot which only caused more pain, suffering, and severe bleeding. So euthanizing may not be the right word to describe this event where the bison was bleeding to death and struggling to stay above water.
Hopefully the locals will release the Zoo America hunting video so that we can see how the “euthanizing” prevented suffering.
September 10, 2011 at 3:33 am
Anonymous
Our deepest condolences to all those at Zoo America. Our hearts go out to you as you continue to care for the other animals. As members of our local zoo, my daughter and I know how much the loss of any animal effects the staff. We are certain everyone did their best during this emergency. Even the best laid plans have their flaws and tragedy can strike at any time. We are only human, afterall. Godspeed as you repair and recover. We look forward to visiting in October.
September 10, 2011 at 4:14 am
Bina
My heart breaks for those beautiful animals and their keepers. We just saw them Monday- magnificent, enormous animals. I am so sorry for your loss.
September 10, 2011 at 4:23 am
Anonymous
MY hope and prayers are that Hershey Zoo America is NEVER EVER allowed to have any animal in their possesion!! It is extremely obvious that they do not know how to treat God’s special creatures. You people make me sick, sick enough to vomit. You are greedy, money hungry bastards that deserve to burn in hell for this!!
September 10, 2011 at 4:25 am
Anne D
Why do you people insist on focusing so much on the fact the zoo remained open until noon that day? Who cares!!!!! I bet any amount of money if the zoo had decided to close all together instead of remaining open until noon that day you would be complaining and criticizing the zoo up and down claiming they had something to hide and what happened to the bison was planned in advance. Ridiculous. I have also read a few comments how the animals are only there for entertainment and kept in enclosures. What do you expect them to do, allow the animals to roam around the zoo at free will endangering humans? How stupid! Zoo’s and enclosures exist mainly for the safety of the animals and to protect the public from harm. Zoo’s are meant to be an educational experience with animals we would not normally have the opportunity to see unless you make it a priority to see them in the wild and have the financial resources to travel all over the world.
It’s funny how these are also some of the same people who have been to this zoo or other zoo’s and go to a circus for entertainment. You are the same ignorant people who never complain or criticize until something bad happens, then you are all about the blame. For all the people claiming they will never step inside Zoo America again, Good! One less ignorant person taking up valuable space in the zoo allowing the rest of us the ability to walk through the zoo without you getting in the way of our view.
The next time any of you people who think you have all the answers and could have done a better job are faced with a life and death situation on your hands in a matter of minutes and choose ending the suffering better make sure you are well prepared to face a firing squad of inquiries afterwards. I hope you are criticized and ridiculed for the choices you make the way you have maliciously attacked the zoo staff.
God bless the comments of Lori, Jodi, Amy and many others who have supported the efforts of the zoo staff. The world needs more compassionate and understanding people like you and less of the highly critical and judgmental ones like Brittany, who is so out of touch with reality to explain to a five year old how life and death experiences happen every day. It’s just a fact of life. What happens if the child’s beloved pet dies? Will they associate your home with being the reason “the place the animal died?” I would rather use it as a teachable moment than turn it into something so scary. How you as an adult personally react will have a much greater impact on how the child will perceive any situation. You freak out and speak negatively about it then whose fault is it when the child has a difficult time processing what they hear in the media or from others? Children also watch the news and see pictures of car wrecks with mangled cars and someone dies. Try shielding them from everything bad in life. Good luck with that one.
September 10, 2011 at 4:25 am
kadoka
Even if the employees did everything they could, it is almost impossible to believe that all of the animals survived. Where are they now? Why aren’t we seeing pictures? The prairie dogs couldn’t have survived in that pit. Where are the others, bears, puma, foxes, wolves? Where are they????????? If the park is under water, surely the zoo is too. Do you think the public is that stupid? I hope PETA shuts down this zoo. Let them use that area for another of their roller coasters and let the animals go somewhere safer for them.
September 10, 2011 at 1:55 pm
Anonymous
To those of you who are bashing the ZooAmerica staff about not being able to save two animals, are you also bashing area farmers who lost livestock in the fast rising flood waters?? Two bison died, get over it! Look at the human lives that would have been lost had the park staff continued to try to move these large animals. Yes, losing an animal or “pet” is a terrible thing and losing them this way is horrible, but the zoo staff was following protocol and history. I imagine that all of you who are mad at the zoo for not saving the boison are also people who have never hunted and killed an animal for sport or simply hit one with your vehiicle.
Good job ZooAmerica staff!! Keep up the good work and I look forward to my next visit to ZooAmerica!!
September 10, 2011 at 2:16 pm
Adam
To those that want to call in PETA. Maybe you might just wanna check and see how many of the animals they “rescue” get euthanized. I don’t think you will be a big supporter any more.
As far as the bison, meh, it sucks that it happened that way, but then again, I can go to the bison farm two miles away and buy bison burgers. I can probably get a couple bison too, if someone needs replacements.
September 10, 2011 at 2:23 pm
kadoka
This isn’t just about losing two animals but about the fact that they want the public to believe no other animals were lost and that just isn’t possible. Why the coverup?
September 10, 2011 at 2:50 pm
- . -
All I see are a bunch of excuses…
September 10, 2011 at 4:34 pm
Joyce
Katie, Katie, Katie. You are a Hershey representative a true blue company person. You are simply put a mouth piece. People are not stupid Katie so why do you insist on saying things that are simply not true. Too many people know the truth about how many animals died – there are pictures and videos. And Katie please explain the tarping. Was that to protect the public from the flood damage at the zoo or from seeing all of the dead animal’s that were not lost in the flood? How are you going to spin things when you actually have to admit that more animals died than was actually first reported? Can’t wait to see how that works out for you! I really do belive Katie that when the zoo reopens I’m going to be seeing a lot of “Closed for renovation” signs on many exhibits. The wolves, the bison, the prairie dogs. Just curious Katie, how are the bears doing? Were they moved to “higher ground” too? Or will that exhibit be renovated too??? Would just love to hear your response if your bosses will let you that is.
September 10, 2011 at 4:59 pm
Ramone
Zoo bashers, here is a new target for your hate:
http://www.ldnews.com/ci_18862781?source=most_viewed
Yes, 14,000 turkeys drowned in the flooding in Lebanon county. Weren’t those farmers watching the weather, which had been saying for days that we’d see flash flooding like we haven’t seen for decades? Oh, that’s right, the weather reports didn’t say anything at all like that because you can’t predict how bad a “flash flood” will be, hence the name.
But I’m sure you all don’t care about the death of 14,000 turkeys since they just would have ended up on your dinner table on Thanksgiving anyway. Not to mention all of the chickens and cattle that are raised to be slaughtered for your consumption everyday at any restaurant or in your local grocery store. You can be assured that the bison at the zoo lived much better lives and were cared for much better for their 13 and 15 years at the zoo than any of the livestock that you chow down on every day.
My thoughts and prayers go out to all of the ZooAmerica staff who are suffering this loss along with the rest of us.
September 10, 2011 at 5:02 pm
Eliza
I have to wonder how those vilifying the employees of Zoo America for the unfortunate deaths feel about the humans who suffered during the flood. It’s true, this area has had a lot of rain in the last few weeks, and there were flood warnings. Despite this, I don’t think anyone in this area expected flooding of this magnitude. I’ve live on the base of a mountain, and our basement flooded for the first time. I’ve lived here 15 years, and we’ve never experienced flooding!
How do you feel about the man who was killed when a wall in his basement collapsed while he was pumping water? How about the woman whose car was overtaken by water on 322? Im friend with the young man who tried to save her, and I can only imagine the anguish he felt as he watched her drown. How about those who live in areas that don’t usually flood, and have lost everything? This will affect them for months, maybe years!
Get off your pedestal, and have some respect for those who put their lives in danger when it became apparent that the flooding was more severe than expected. For those of you harping about the zoo being open until noon: how many of you went to work, school, went about your daily business wednesday morning? How many of you scoffed when some schools started to release students early? Stop being so self righteous and hypocritical!
I feel bad for the poor animals, and I hope that they did not suffer long. I feel worse for the humans whose suffering will continue for a great deal longer.
September 10, 2011 at 5:10 pm
Ramone
Joyce, Joyce, Joyce. WIll you apologize publicly when you’re assertions that many more animals died turn out to be wrong? Of course not, because the beauty of the internet is that you can say what you want and not have to back it up with actual facts. Maybe you’re not seeing the bears and wolves because they are safely in their dens until the zoo can be sure that their exhibits are free of dangerous debris and the fences are secure. Maybe the tarps were put up so the grieving zoo staff didn’t have to deal with the gawking onlookers who are just there to get a look, or better yet a photo, of the poor bison who died. Just like the horrible Westboro Baptist Church members that show up at the funerals of our service men and women, the onlookers and gawkers are just looking for a way to get some attention for themselves on their Facebook page.
September 10, 2011 at 5:51 pm
Joyce
Ramone, Ramone, Ramone. So what department in Hershey do you work in? And if you don’t work for Hershey you really should apply – you’d make a great company man ! Or Ramone, are you that gullible to actually believe what this greedy corporation is feeding you? Oh Ramone, I hope you are not disappointed when you visit the zoo and see all of the empty exhibits.
September 10, 2011 at 6:22 pm
Anonymous
I see a lot of interchanging of “moving to higher ground” (moving within the pen) and “relocating.” In one answer, the zoo wrote about just moving the animals to higher ground within their inclosures, which includes the bison. But then, in another answer, the zoo writes that they had begun to relocate animals prior to Wednesday which is a protocol when necessary. So it’s sort of double-talk in my opinion. Of course it was done effectively in the past, but you have to take into account what is happening now. ZOOAmerica now has proof it needs a second location for the animals for when hurricanes and tropical storms hit the area.
Take a page of Six Flags Wild Safari’s book (Jackson, New Jersey). In Hurricane Irene’s preparations, the keepers there moved all of the animals days prior to that Saturday night into their winter headquarters and were stocked with 30 days worth of food. Now, some people on here might argue that this was a flash flood. Yes, I get that. However, flooding was predicted. The Northeast was preparing for a slow-moving Tropical Storm Lee; this type of storm is known for slowing down or even stalling which can and does lead to catastrophic flooding. It’s history from Louisiana to Pennsylvania was showing its capabilities. And to top it off, ZOOAmerica admits to enacting its flood emergency protocol as early as Monday.
For following old protocol, these people gave Ryan a humane way to not suffer; unfortunately, Esther suffered and drowned. And I do feel bad for the person who had the most dreadful task with Ryan. But with this knowledge that storms like T.S. Lee and the damage the creek within the zoo can do, things must change. Emergency plans need to be revisited and revamped. And before they obtain new bison, they need to redesign the bison pen in order to prevent (heaven forbid) another incident like this – especially if flooding happens as dangerously fast as it had on Wednesday. And there needs to be a secondary location for all animals.
Now this is how I understand what has happened, based on this blog, others’ comments, and newsreports. I have been to ZOOAmerica on multiple occasions in the 10 years I have visited Hershey consecutively. I do not doubt the love and care the staff has for all of the animals, but something dropped the ball – most likely an outdated protocol which needed a “worse-case scenario” plan. If you decide I am ignorant, then I cannot help you.
Arguing about what happened and name-calling will not bring back Esther and Ryan. However, reflection can help the rest of the animals and future bison additions to the zoo.
September 10, 2011 at 7:37 pm
kadoka
I don’t understand why everyone is attacking each other. It is inappropriate.
Everyone has their own feelings about what happened but that doesn’t give anyone the right to attack those who think differently.
I have all the sympathy there is to give about the people who work with and love the animals but this is not the first time animals drowned at that zoo. This is a greedy company that does not care about it employess yet alone animals. Have you followed at all the way they treat their employees?
As far as condemning others about the human loss, this is a blog created by the Zoo and there are other blogs for that. This was created by the zoo and should be about the zoo, not any other factor in this flooding.
If Hershey would stop covering up the truth about how many animals died that day, they would probably recieve a lot more sympathy. Just like the man who said coyotes cried for hours and Hershey responded with we don’t have coyotes, They knew he was talking about the wolves and that response triggers doubt in people’s minds. All of it has been handled wrong but as bad as the loss of life is the lies about it.
We need to come together to heal not condemn others who feel differently. We have the freedom to think and feel as we want.
September 10, 2011 at 8:59 pm
Laureen
We all have a range of emotions from being upset to sad to angry. A picture is worth a thousand words. We can’t see that the animals are all safe now. I am sure there are a lot of things to address but I would ask that pictures are taken to show us the wolves are OK and the other animals rescued. It would give us peace of mind. Post them on the web site and get them to the media.
I would also like to know what HERCO and Hershey Trust is going to do to make sure this never happens again. Will areas of the zoo be built up or will the zoo be relocated? Will there be something done in rememberance of the animals that lost their lives, the Bison, Esther and Ryan? Show us you care through action.
September 10, 2011 at 9:08 pm
Lorena Rivadeneira
I do understand that natural disasters occur that no one welcomes or expects, but we are continually advised to “be ready” and have a plan of action. Your company has, without a doubt, responded to this as any business owner would in trying to answer to those concerned. But I feel truly angered that these animals had to die this way at the hands of those that are there to protect them. At the end, when there was no other choice, the right thing was done to euthanize as I can only begin to imagine what a horrible way to die by drowning would be. I can also see that I’m sure zoo keepers were doing their best to try and do what they could for them, but there is always a higher up that controls these decisions and that person must be held accountable for his/her poor decision making. At the end, this is what it was… I’ve read so many posts on this stating that there were so many things to do – action is always the best decision. I’m sure your company will look to fix this unfortunate situation where you are in an area that is prone to flooding with defenseless animals trapped in their habitat enclosures. I’m sure ZooAmerica understands that this can not happen again – for the passionate zookeepers I’m sure they are hurting on the loss of these creatures; for the big wigs, their pockets may feel the pain because of bad press that their organization will, without a doubt, receive. This is a HUGE FAIL…
September 10, 2011 at 9:24 pm
Laureen
Also for those who want to help and make a difference for the animals going forward, what can be done if anything? Post on your zoo website updates, let us know.
September 10, 2011 at 11:22 pm
Anonymous
These animals rely on the humans to keep them safe and alive…the bison were helpless. Stating that these animals were like your family is an understatement…would you leave you family members in these conditions? The weather forecast began as early as Sunday for HEAVY rains. I am absolutely saddened at this accident and will forever look at Zoo America with different eyes =’(
September 11, 2011 at 12:27 am
LouieS
I find the response that the bison “were moved to higher ground within their enclosure earlier in the week” to be insufficient to the point of being misleading. I walked by Zoo America on Trinidad Ave. today. The term “higher ground” is relative. The bison enclosure is not large, has little slope, and borders directly on the creek. As the inches of rain continued to accumulate over the days, I can’t believe anyone who has ever seen a flash flood would gamble on any part of that enclosure remaining safe for animals. The elk enclosure goes up a steep hill leading to a much higher elevation. The hill plus the greater distance from the creek explains why the elk were safe. I couldn’t see the wolves’ enclosure well enough from the street to draw any conclusions about how much danger they were in. I bet it was too close for comfort.
I think whoever was in charge erred by not monitoring the cumulative rainfall and taking action to get the bison out of that enclosure before the water had a chance to rise over the creek bank. It is obviously too late to do much once the animals are surrounded by rushing water. It is my sincerest hope that changes will be made to that enclosure and to the disaster plan to prevent animals from ever being exposed to this danger again. Also needed is someone with common sense and decisiveness to make the call when a situation gets risky. You can’t always count on things happening the way they have before.
September 11, 2011 at 12:57 am
Tracy Keen
After hearing about this tragedy I’ve been haunted by the images of the bison wading through rising water and ultimately being submerged in it. I have no doubt that the zoo staff feels the same and did everything they could to help the animals within their means. I place blame on the pencil pushers who see $ signs and profit/loss reports rather than living creatures. The flooding has been an issue for years regardless of how quick they happen. There was plenty of time to plan for future incidences and make changes to the habitats. My family has supported Hersheypark for 40+ years during the summer, Halloween, and Christmas. I can assure you it won’t be in our future.
September 11, 2011 at 2:10 am
Anonymous
Lets see, new multi million producing dollar stadium, new multi million dollar producing rides, where does the money go? Not back into improving other areas like the so called zoo. I grew up on a dairy farm and we kept calves in a bigger area. Why would you put 2000 pound plus animals at the lowest area? Common sense would state you make it where you can move the biggest animals the soonest. Money talks and thats all HERCO wants to hear.
September 11, 2011 at 2:40 am
Anonymous
Do some people not realize that bison are wild animals and are not exactly prone to wanting to move? I’m certainly not happy that the bison died, but you have to realize that they did what they could. Really, where would you put 2 fully grown bison and how would you get them there? They’re not dairy cows. They’re not domesticated. They’re not easy to move. Yes, it is tragic. But flooding is part of nature. Animals die in floods. The fact that the zoo keepers tried to rescue one, and then didn’t let the other suffer is what their job called them to do.
September 11, 2011 at 2:54 am
Becca
This was a horrible situation. It was also horrible to watch the buffalo struggle to survive. I feel sorry for the animals that did die. I also feel sorry that this company feels the need to “chocolate coat” the real facts. As if denying that any other animals died as a result of this is going to make it any less sad. The staff acted too late, the pen where the animals were kept became a death trap. The video proves it. Too bad for Hershey that the internet exists. I feel sorry for the poor PR department – they have their work cut out for them on this one that’s for sure! Too much bad press already they really couldn’t afford for this to happen too. I hope that because of this that the zoo only handles animals that it can exhibit in the buildings on site. The set up just cannot handle these larger animals, nor can their “emergency plan”.
September 11, 2011 at 3:03 am
Anonymous
About them not wanting to move, look at the first part of that sentence. They are wild and the are always moving in the wild, they graze. Plus wild animals will naturally seek higher ground, no higher ground in a pen. Give them a opening to a truck with with good food in it and they would have moved within a day.
September 11, 2011 at 8:42 am
AK
This being the 10th Anniversary of September 11th Americans are still so quick to point their finger and blame at any situation that even was an accident and this a force of nature. PEOPLE lost their lives in this flood, not just the 2 bison at Zoo America. The devistation is terrible around this town. The day the flood came, there were no roads in or out of Hershey. It will take a while to rebuild most of Central and NorthEastern PA. As i know Katrina was much more devistating in the South. And many other disasters around this country in the past. Accidents happen in this life, we can not control the force of mother nature and how quickly things occur at her grasp. I feel sorry for those who have anger in their hearts and minds over this what was an accident. I believe that if these animals, which weight upwards of 2800 lbs. would have most likely seriously injured or killed any person in their way considering the incoming flood in their zoo habitat. Thank GOD that did not happen. I ask you, have you ever tried to move a large animal, i.e buffalo, while they were threatened by any type of danger (flood waters) animals get stressed more so than people. They also have large horns. I just thank the Lord no zoo keepers were hurt during this, and thank GOD that no human life was lost in the zoo. I feel sorry for the zoo keepers who were close to these animals, i understand it takes a special talent to work with such animals, it is unfortunate that such a accident has occured. I pray for them in this difficult time and speak peace and healing over them. And i hope that these sticks and stones thrown at them in the form of human words do not peirce them deeply. Think before you speak, get the facts before you accuse. And for goodness sake come together and stop placing blame. Everyday accidents happen. Move on, let it go. Much much worse has happend in the world. Get over it, i hope you ask for forgiveness for such harsh words spoken to these people. Lets start working together for a common goal, love and forgiveness. Look at the bigger picture. Not just this small, unfortunate fragment.
September 11, 2011 at 1:38 pm
Anonymous
@AK – You are on a zoo’s blog where people will be discussing the animals and what occurred. There are other places to discuss the lives of people that were lost in the floods. So, unless these people were living in the zoo and died in the flood, I suggest you let us continue to speak about what has happened here at ZOOAmerica instead of reprimanding people for caring about 2 bison which lost their lives when they didn’t have to. Furthermore,it has nothing to do with 9/11. Please, I wish you and others would stop making the bison lives sound so trivial. In one respect, you want people to think about the other people and respect the work of the zoo’s staff. In another respect, you want us to move on because “much much worse has happened in the world. Get over it…” Which is it? Do you want us to feel sorry for the staff or not? In your second statement, you are basically trivializing the work the zoo does. Please, I ask you to think before you write.
If you notice, people are asking questions. There are a few unanswered questions some of us think still linger, and we ask the zoo to answer them. It’s not being harsh or throwing stones. When something like this happens in a zoo, we can only ask since people want to think plans for such events are there all the time. We do not need to ask forgiveness for asking questions.
September 11, 2011 at 2:01 pm
sheila l.
wow…I am all for freedom of speech and everything but wow…I feel alot of this is because they were some of the largest animals in the zoo. Would all of this be so blown out of control if were smaller animals? If the reports came out that only two endangerd snakes or birds lost their lives? I think not. The bigger the animal the bigger the noise
I applaud the efforts of the humans that were there doing everything they could. Notice, humans, not corporations or chocolate…humans. Stop making this about companies…and remember that humans were involved. Humans with feelings and families that had to go home and tell their children that they had to make very hard decisions at work that day. Then probably had to take care of their own flooded basements.
September 12, 2011 at 12:31 pm
Kevin B.
I think everyone needs to back off of the Zoo staff! I am in a business which requires me to formulate emergency preparedness plans for every possible scenario from weather to bombings, I have taken multiple courses through FEMA and DHS, and even the instructors of the courses will tell you that sometimes, no matter how thorough we plan, things happen beyond our control. You are only seeing 2 animals here, what you are neglecting to do or just choosing not to out of a hateful heart, is thank the zoo for saving countless other lives. Maybe people should take some time and read the Bible to see why things have started getting so bad, and realize that His plans always supersede our plans. My prayers go out to the ZooAmerica staff and all the residents of PA, NY, MD, and other states affected by the flooding. May God bless you all!
September 12, 2011 at 2:23 pm
Candi
There are no coyotes in this zoo, so there’s your answer to that question (for the few people who still keep bringing that up).
Also, the keepers at ZooAmerica deserve more respect than some on here are giving. They did everything they could within their power, but the higher-ups only fund so much. Bison are aggressive animals, so you can’t just herd them out of the exhibit. It requires $$ and better exhibit structure…and the ability to predict the future? The flooding was unpredictable. To everyone who suddenly has this omniscient outlook on what the zoo should have done…screw you.
Oh, and stop putting words in zookeepers’ mouths.
September 12, 2011 at 3:19 pm
LouieS
I am very disappointed to see that Zoo America is censoring the comments to this blog. My 2nd post was removed which otherwise would be displayed between the post of sheila l. and Kevin B. I don’t know why it was removed. It was a logical, well-written post that provided some factual information for readers. It was anything but an emotional rant. Possibly I provided too much information about actual requirements by organizations that certify zoos. Perhaps it was removed because I asked probing questions about who exactly was resposible for the decisions that were made that ultimately led to the deaths of the bison. The public has a right to ask questions of Zoo America. I am disappointed that my post was removed.
September 12, 2011 at 3:42 pm
LouieS
One more comment for readers. Unless you have more than one computer, you may never know if your post is taken down by Zoo America. They are pretty “cagey” (pun intended). When I review comments to the blog from the computer I used to make my post, it looks like my comments are still there and everything is in order. It is only when I check the blog from a different computer, not the one I used to originally submit my comments, I see that they took it down. I’m not liking this….
September 12, 2011 at 4:08 pm
Jane
My post has disappeared –I was not aware that anyone could do that–it was a well written truthful account of observance and experience with the Hershey Zoo and surrounding area during heavy rains and previous floods and had many questions concerning the situation with the bison and the efficiency of those who are the decision-makers for the zoo-
September 12, 2011 at 4:17 pm
LouieS
Things are becoming clear to me now. If you make a post and shortly afterwards see the phrase “Your comment is awaiting moderation”, Zoo America is taking steps to have it taken down. They are in the process of once again removing my second post, that I later re-posted (minus 2 questions), apparently so as to prevent the public from knowing facts about what zoos are required to do to be accredited by the AZA and what regulatory bodies oversee zoo procedures. Why would they want to hide that information from the public?
September 12, 2011 at 4:56 pm
LouieS
I guess what keeps getting me in trouble with Zoo America is the information I’ve provided. Since they are in the process of removing me second post AGAIN, I’ll try one more thing to get the information out there. I’ll try removing the actual link to the information I refer to in the post but leave all the rest of my information in place. Here goes:
A post on another web site stated that the AZA would investigate the incident. I did a search on AZA and found that it stands for the Association of Zoos and Aquariums. Zoo America is an accredited zoo with that organization. On the AZA web site is a pdf document that describes the standards expected of accredited zoos: Look it up for yourself.
The questions we are asking as members of the public are entirely appropriate. Page 18 of the AZA’s accreditation standards says zoos are expected to have procedures in place for emergencies involving the weather/environment and that there are to be drills and training of staff for those kinds of emergencies. Records are to be kept of staff training. I didn’t read the document thoroughly but I would guess that it is expected that an evacuation plan be in place for each and every animal a zoo maintains. I would expect that if you aren’t equipped to manage the animal in an emergency, you shouldn’t have it on site. So the questions keep coming up…. was a plan in place, was required training conducted, and was necessary equipment available to be able to move the bison in an emergency?
The AZA document indicates there are other local, state, and federal wildlife laws that must be complied with. Maybe someone else will do some homework and let all the rest of us know what those laws might be for Dauphin County/Derry Township.
I started out believing there was a flash flood that came up rapidly that led to this tragedy. Having experienced a couple of flash floods myself, I felt zoo personnel should have been prepared for that considering the layout of the bison enclosure and the creek. But then I read posts that said there was not a flash flood but a gradual rise of the water over a period of hours. Now I am even more convinced that the decision makers at the zoo really blew it.
****The above is a SECOND re-post of an earlier post that was censored and removed by Zoo America. The only differences from my earlier posts is that I have deleted 2 sentences (actually 2 questions) and a hyperlink that were in the earlier post. I am re-submitting this information to try to find out exactly what it was that prompted Zoo America to censor and delete my comments/questions. We can now see if these comments remain up for others to read.
September 12, 2011 at 6:11 pm
Alex
Bravo to you LouieS ! Glad your post finally made it through the censors !!! This is a topic that ZooAmerica people cannot tarp over. I’m so thankful that someone is going to investigate this. The video alone speaks volumes.
September 12, 2011 at 6:19 pm
PAgal
I was unfortunately in Hershey on Wednesday, September 7th when all this happened. At noon, there was a little flooding in typical flooding areas. By 1pm, the whole town was in chaos. It happened so fast. Even the employees at the Pizza Hut on Rt.39 had to jump out of the window to save themselves from the water. So for all the posters who criticize the zoo staff for not caring for the animals or not moving fast enought were obviously not in Hershey that day. They did all they could. My heart breaks for the bison as my family was there that Monday on Labor Day at the zoo/park. We love to visit the zoo all year round and will contunue to support them. If you were not there, then keep your comments to yourself. It took me 2 hours to travel 4 miles to get my kids out of school that day. I would have never been in Hershey that day if I knew that 6 inches of rain would come down in a few hours and the whole town would be flooded, but only God had that much insight on that day. My prayers and thoughts go to the zoo staff and everyone in Hershey that were affected by this flood.
September 13, 2011 at 1:02 am
Anonymous
@Shelia – I would be just as upset if it was upset if it were two turtles who died or any other small animal ZOOAmerica has. It has nothing to do with the size of the animal. It has to do with how ZOOAmerica dealt with this. If you’re planning for flooding two days away, basically you’d think they come out of this with 100% of their animals. ZOOAmerica failed their two bison.
September 13, 2011 at 5:10 am
Kathleen
God Bless everyone while you mourn and rebuild. I am sure HP staff did the best they could under extreme conditions.
September 13, 2011 at 5:26 am
Kathleen
Isn’t it funny that most if the negative comments are “anonymous”, if you are really so concerned have the b…s to post under your name.
September 13, 2011 at 1:21 pm
Anonymous
Katleen – Isn’t it funny you didn’t sign your whole name.
September 13, 2011 at 7:22 pm
kadoka
I asked the news team at one of the local stations to go in and see the animals and then Hershey confirmed that all the prairie dogs drowned. This is just as upsetting as the bison. They said they wouldn’t come out of their holes. Couldn’t the ground have been dug up to get them out? Days ahead of the flash flood when other animals were moved to safety. It isn’t just the bison. It is any animal that died there or any human injured trying to save the animals. I have no problem with zoo staff. It is the people who created the exit plan.
September 14, 2011 at 1:00 am
Anonymous
What about the 6 prairie dogs?
September 14, 2011 at 2:19 am
Rebecca C
My heart goes out to your staff, as do my prayers. This is be a trying time for all of you, and I truly feel for y’all.
September 14, 2011 at 4:09 am
Anonymous
I just read that not all of the prairie dogs are accounted for due to the fact they bury their dead. I think ZOOAmerica won’t allow for a link, but just google it. You’ll see one article appear about it. And another article stated they don’t know how many actually live at the Zoo. So who knows?
September 15, 2011 at 3:42 pm
Alex
Hmm found some wolves on Trinidad and had to tranquilize them. Interesting. Hey Katie care to comment on this interesting development ???
September 21, 2011 at 3:06 pm
Michelle
Where is some of this information coming from? Alex- wolves on Trinidad? The close call during Ivan? All the prairie dogs being confirmed dead? If we are getting the wrong answers, or censored ones, please post somewhere we can find them.
September 23, 2011 at 11:27 am
katiezoo
Michelle-
For answers to all of your questions, please read the 3 blogs pertaining to the flood. To reiterate- wolves were always safe and secure during the flood. 9 prairie dogs survived the flood. Also, we experienced some flooding during Ivan, but nothing compared to the recent flood from Tropical Storm Lee. We did not lose any animals from Ivan, nor were the bison in danger during that flood.
September 23, 2011 at 5:05 pm
Jane
Despite all the excuses offered by zookeepers and officials of Herco–there is no reason that the animals should have drown —the weather report was very bad and warned of flooding early in the week–Spring Creek always rises during alot of rain much less flooding—those animals should have been moved early in the week to be safe rather than sorry–it is the zoo’s incompetence and lack of understanding of how quickly creeks can rise with torrential rains coupled with flood predictions that were obviously ignored that caused the problem–I lived in an apartment in the zoo many years ago and the creek was too close to the animal cages for safety during heavy rains then so why did everyone wait and say that the waters rose too quickly????? If the attention had been on safety of the animals on Monday instead of keeping the zoo open until the last minute to make some more money and then claiming the “water came up too quickly”–is plain old greed and neglect and ignorance—SPRING CREEK HAS ALWAYS RISEN QUICKLY even in a hard rain——Who didn’t care and use their brain to think of the animals welfare?????
October 3, 2011 at 12:38 am
Tracy Gipe
I am astonished at how many of you are so quick to bash the zoo staff for not knowing it was going to flood so deeply. Really? Are you all that perfect that you’ve never based a decision on past experience then had it go wrong? The water hasn’t been that high since 1972!! If you’re local you’ll remember people reporting watching the water rise on 39 in minutes. MINUTES. Not days, not hours but minutes to submerge Pizza Hut. I was at the zoo today. It was sad to see the empty Bison enclosure but I know members of the staff there and I could see there is a higher part of their enclosure.
So to those of you that are so fast to blame the zoo, where do you propose they put those two huge animals? Do you think they just leash them up and walk them away? Do you also plan to go around to neighboring towns and berate the folks who lost their homes and possessions for living where it could flood??
I agree with someone above who said good for all of you who said you’ll never return. Less of you judgmental know-it-alls to ruin my peaceful zoo visit.